• Joseph’s Blog
  • Respect
  • The Lords of Greenwich
  • The Neglected and Abused
  • Contact
  • Crossword Puzzles
  • Archives
  • All Posts
  • Home

Joseph Bentivegna, M.D.February 27, 2017

    Donald Trump Should Replace Obamacare with a Universal Health Safety Net

 

 

November 27, 2016

 

President-elect Trump has promised to repeal Obamacare but thus far has been vague about alternatives. Rather than tinker with the system, Mr. Trump should boldly propose that all Americans have a Universal Health Safety Net that protects individuals and families from huge health care bills while lowering premiums for the middle class and working poor. The most straight-forward solution is to provide every American with government-backed catastrophic health insurance.

Because of technological advances, bureaucratic mandates and an out-of-control legal system, the average annual health care costs according to the actuarial firm Milliman, Inc. is $24,671 a year for a family of four. Those who are not self-employed pay $10,473 out-of-pocket while the employee pays the balance. Middle class wages have been stagnant for over two decades and now average $53,657 a year.  When the employee contribution is included, many workers are paying almost 30% of their wages for health care.

Providing a Universal Safety Net does not require a new government program. It already exists. It is called Medicare – a plan that protects our elderly and disabled from large health care bills. All that is necessary is to extend Medicare to all Americans for medical bills that exceed $75,000 a year. Purchasing insurance to cover this first $75,000 would be inexpensive.  This would be financed by increasing the Medicare tax (presently 2.9%).  The vast majority of citizens would see their health care bills plummet to around $4,000 a year.

Further cost containment could be realized by classifying diseases and treatments according to efficacy and level of seriousness. It is well known that removing lung tumors before they have spread or treating hypertension and glaucoma saves and improves patients’ lives. Other treatments – back surgery without a herniated disc, prostate cancer and colon cancer chemotherapy in those over eighty years old – are controversial. These treatments could be partially covered and patients could decide if they wanted to pay out-of-pocket for them or else purchase extra coverage.

Furthermore, bureaucratic mandates are requiring doctors to waste endless time inputting useless data for the government to peruse while the complaints of patients are being ignored. Doctors are literally dealing with an Kafkaesque maze of acronyms – HIIPA, MIPS, QPP, APM, CEHRT, MACRA, PQRS (don’t ask) – that do nothing more than waste time.

Tort reform is crucial too. Forcing doctors to perform unnecessary tests adds 15 percent to medical costs. Doctors are also afraid to use modern technology such as e-mail, Twitter, Skype and Facebook to service their patients. Indemnifying doctors for these modalities would enable elderly patient and disabled patients to be consulted without leaving their homes and decrease the need for family members to take time off work, saving billions of dollars in worker productivity.

This plan would also have several political benefits. First of all, it would attract bipartisan support. Many Democrats would see this as a reasonable compromise to the socialistic plan proposed by Bernie Sanders during his presidential campaign. Secondly, it would allow President Trump to negotiate better trade deals as the health care costs for corporations would decrease. Finally, it would decrease resentment towards illegal immigrants who receive free health care while those who are citizens of the country and forced not only to pay outrageous premiums, but taxes to support the  emergency rooms that give the illegals free care. Lowering health care costs would make many more receptive to a reasonable plan to allow more immigrants.

The rise and fall of the Trump presidency will be determined by the upward mobility he can create for the working class who has been left behind by globalization – the so-called deplorables that Hillary Clinton and the liberal media enjoyed ridiculing.  If President Trump and the Republicans extend coverage to all Americans for catastrophic coverage, not only will they be doing the country a great service; but they will enable small businesses and corporations to thrive.

Facebook Comments

Filed Under: All Articles, Blog, Health Care Reform

Comments

  1. Bill Pomper says

    March 22, 2017 at 7:10 pm

    Have you forwarded your proposal to our senators and your congressman? It makes far more sense than the “Trumpcare repeal and replace???” bill presently being debated.
    As an unapologetic liberal I would prefer universal single payer coverage for all, but as a realist I understand that ain’t going to happen tomorrow! If you haven’t, I would like to present it to Senators Blumenthal and Murphy, and my representative Joe Courtney.
    Obviously it would need to be introduced by a Republican congressman to have any prayer of being considered, but would like somehow to plant the seed and get the ball rolling!

    Reply
    • Joseph Bentivegna, M.D. says

      May 27, 2017 at 8:19 am

      Bill

      Sorry I took so long to get back to you. Thank your comment. I will be making videos and setting up a web site promoting the idea and will keep you posted.

      Regards,
      Joe Bentivegna

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Doctor Bentivegna is an ophthalmologist living in Connecticut. He has written numerous op-ed pieces for The Hartford Courant and The New York Times regarding health care, tort reform, and the political situation in Haiti.

Respect

An edgy and often hilarious exploration of barely concealed racism told as a taut page-turner that ranges through a kaleidoscope of ethnic experiences and economic classes. This novel, Respect, is sure to have people talking.

$17.95Add to cart


The Neglected and Abused: A Physician's Year in Haiti

haiti

The most moving account of the situation in Haiti ever written by a non-Haitian. Haiti-Observateur

$19.95Add to cart


When to Refuse Treatment

Described by Aging Magazine as "frank, sensitive and specific."

$17.95Add to cart


The Lords of Greenwich

The Lords of Greenwich

Compelling from start to finish...a must read novel. Gerry Demeusy, Crime Reporter, The Hartford Courant.

$19.95Add to cart


Recent Posts

  • Deposit your money in JNLB (Joe’s Never Lose Bank)
  • There is No Such Thing as UFO’s
  • The Slippery Slope of Physician-Assisted Suicide is Coming to Connecticut
  • Bail Out of Silicon Valley Bank Depositors is an Outrage
  • President Biden May Have Parkinson’s Disease
  • Joseph’s Blog
  • Respect
  • The Lords of Greenwich
  • The Neglected and Abused
  • Contact
  • Crossword Puzzles
  • Archives
  • All Posts
  • Home

Copyright Joseph Bentivegna © 2023 · Log in